Flavors: Chocolate, Vanilla, Wild berries, Chai
Naturade VeganSmart All-in-one Nutritional Shake is not actually a protein powder, and yet I chose to try and review it anyways.
That’s because it has a substantial amount of protein for a general nutrition shake.
That being said, I held it to the same standards that I do for all normal plant based protein powders.
This review is divided into the 4 main factors behind buying a protein powder, complete with the formulas and methods used to determine the score for each.
If you'd like recommendations for a more conventional protein powder, take a look at the best overall vegan protein powders.
I always start with nutrition since the whole point of drinking a protein shake is to get protein.
The nutrition score for each powder I review is based on what percent of the total calories come from protein.
The higher the percentage of protein, the high the score.
These are relative scores among protein powders:
Here’s the formula that I use to calculate the nutrition score:
The only variables it looks at is total calories, and calories of protein.
Both of these can be found on the nutrition label.
Plugging in these numbers, we get a nutrition score of 14.
This means that compared to other vegan protein powders, VeganSmart has a relatively low amount of protein compared to total calories.
It still does have 20 grams per shake, which may be enough for you if you’re just looking for a protein shake as a casual way to get a little extra protein.
If you’re an athlete, you’ll probably want to go with a protein powder with a better nutrition score.
Part of the reason that VeganSmart scores so poorly here is that it’s an “all-in-one” powder, with a ton of ingredients:
I’ll let you decide if those extra ingredients are particularly important to you.
Next up is comparing the price of VeganSmart to other vegan protein powders.
To start with, VeganSmart comes in a few different confusing sizes. They’re all almost identical in size, but I technically found 3 different sizes while researching the product, which also depend on the flavor.
Here are the 2 most common sizes and the lowest price I could find for each:
In order to calculate a pricing score, I developed a simple formula that adjusts the price per 100 grams of a protein powder to a score out of 25. A high score is a good thing, it means it’s cheaper.
To fairly compare all the products, I use the price per 100 grams of the size closest to 1 kg (2.2 lbs), which is the most widely used size.
Putting in the pricing data above, we get a pricing score of 16.15.
This means that VeganSmart is on the cheaper side of vegan protein powders, although it’s pretty close to the average.
This is the final factor that I can objectively calculate.
Being able to mix well is an important property of a protein powder in most situations. Unless you always plan on using a blender, you want a powder that won’t clump.
To test this property, I extract the clumps and measure how much they weigh in a realistic scenario.
Here are the basic steps:
That final weight is put into the following formula to generate a mixability score:
This powder mixes really well, and there were no clumps to even weight.
It gets a straightforward, perfect mixability score of 25.
Finally we come to taste.
You very well may have different tastes than me, which makes this difficult.
To make the taste score as useful as possible, I assign a score based on this table:
Amazing, would drink for enjoyment alone.
Drinkable, not really good or bad.
A bit of a struggle to get down
The table helps to keep my ratings consistent.
In addition, I try to explain my thoughts behind each taste rating so you can decide if it makes sense to you.
For VeganSmart, I had a few main observations:
Those issues rule out a perfect score for sure.
I think it could be ranked anywhere from 15-20 depending on the person, but personally I felt it was significantly closer to 15.
Therefore, I assigned a taste rating of 15 to this protein powder.
Overall, as far as a vegan protein powder goes, VeganSmart is very average.
It mixes great, but that’s balanced out by having a very weak protein content.
Both taste and price are slightly above average, but nothing special.
I think that VeganSmart is a great protein powder if you detest clumps, or are looking for a casual vegan protein powder that also gives you vitamins, minerals, and digestive enzymes.
VeganSmart has a lot going for it if you're interested in additional nutrition other than just protein, but lacks in important areas that we've looked at. Here are some alternatives that taste better, have more protein, and some extra nutrition.